A Hidden Gem Beneath Times Square

Tucked away inside the 50th Street subway station in Times Square, See No Evil Pizza isn’t your typical New York City pizzeria. This underground eatery is a slice of punk rock nostalgia, serving up bold, flavor-packed pizzas and small plates in an unexpected setting. With fermented dough, high-quality Italian ingredients, and an edgy atmosphere, this spot is quickly making waves in NYC’s competitive pizza scene.

A Subway Surprise Worth Seeking Out

Located at 210 W. 50th St., New York, NY, See No Evil Pizza occupies a former Dunkin’ Donuts space inside the subway station, transformed into a retro-inspired pizzeria. The décor features black-and-white checkered floors, neon lights, and the sounds of 80s punk rock, creating an experience that’s equal parts gritty and nostalgic.

Unlike the classic slice shops above ground, this hidden gem focuses on artisanal whole pies, made with a three-day fermented dough and topped with top-tier Italian ingredients.

The Must-Try Pies

Every 12-inch pizza at See No Evil starts with a raw tomato sauce base, fresh mozzarella, and premium toppings that elevate it to the next level.

🔥 Hell Pie – A fiery creation topped with spicy soppressata, chili-infused honey, and fresh herbs, striking the perfect balance between heat and sweetness.

🍄 Fungi Pizza – A mushroom lover’s dream, layered with roasted wild mushrooms, creamy ricotta, and a hint of truffle oil for an earthy depth of flavor.

🥦 Broccoli Rabe & Sausage – A New York-style classic reimagined with bitter greens, savory sausage, and a sprinkle of pecorino romano.

Beyond Pizza: Small Plates with Big Flavor

While pizza is the star, See No Evil also delivers a curated selection of small plates that showcase the same dedication to quality and creativity.

• Toast alla Veloce – A unique bite featuring fresh sardines, caper-mint salsa, mozzarella, and Fresno chili on crispy polenta bread.

• Seasonal Beans in Walnut Sauce – A rich and hearty dish that changes with the seasons, showcasing fresh produce in a creamy, nutty sauce.

The Sweetest Finale

End your meal with See No Evil’s signature dessert—a vanilla soft serve topped with olive oil and sea salt. The contrast between sweet, salty, and creamy makes for an unexpectedly delightful bite.

Why You Need to Visit See No Evil Pizza

This subway-level pizzeria proves that great food can be found in the most unexpected places. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza fan, an adventurous foodie, or just looking for a unique dining experience, See No Evil Pizza is a must-visit in NYC.

When it comes to hidden food gems in New York City, See No Evil Pizza is one worth seeking out—even if it means heading underground.